Thinky Awards 2026 Nominee Impressions
2026-11-19 Roundup

Come one, come all, it's time again for the Thinky Games awards!
I'm lucky enough to be a juror for the third year running. I've spent the past week trying out some of the best thinky games released this year and I'm excited to write about my time with them. I only get so much time with each title, but I try to play enough to produce an informed opinion.
Where relevant, reviews are scored out of 4.
Here are all the nominees I've played, in alphabetical order:
20 More, Somehow Even Smaller, Mazes

Another delightful outing from FLEB. Pint sized, clever, and beautifully put together as always. Can't beat the price either! (free) Has great Steam Controller support, too! Basically a perfect hour of entertainment.
868-BACK

I liked that the gameplay itself is simple but there's a lot of strategic depth at play. Each run is made of many smaller runs, so there's constant variation, too. The art has a chaotic hacker energy that I generally enjoyed, but its commitment to the bit hurt legibility a little. Enemies are "tasks", abilities are "progs", passive abilities are "devs", etc. It's a cool vibe, but deciphering and evaluating options would take a lot of practice.
Over ~6 (brief) runs, I got wiped out early every time. It was probably me playing too quickly and impulsively, but I also get the sense that real progression here would take a lot of time. ... That said, I ended every run wanting immediately wanting to try again, so there may just be something here. Time will tell, I guess.
Verdict: I am drawn to it, but discouraged by its difficulty. TBD.
A Little Perspective

My initial impression was very good: the art is pleasant, there's a story told through a voiceover, and it's Escher-like premise is both interesting and immediately apparent. Sort of like Monument Valley, but actually hard.
Unfortunately, I found the puzzles themselves a little obtuse. Solving a puzzle relies on a firm understanding of how your perspective affects where/how you can move. But try as I might, I wasn't able to form a consistent set of rules for what was possible. I solved a few puzzles by accident when I made what seemed like it should have been an impossible move, which wasn't satisfying.
That said, even in my short time playing it, it pulls a few cheeky little tricks. So it seems clever and lovingly crafted, but maybe not for me.
Verdict: Appreciated it for what it was, but unlikely to revisit.
The Art of Reflection

I appreciated what the game was putting down, but I find that pure puzzlers aren't really my style these days. I liked that there was some timing required for some sections though. The teleportation mechanic was unique and the mirror stuff & shifting gravity got mind-bending quickly. The music was good too! It's well-made, just not something I'll spend a lot of time with.
Verdict: Mind bending, but not really my style.
The Artisan of Glimmith

A beautifully, cozy little spatial puzzle game. The stained glass theme is brilliant, even if I didn't engage much with the custom colors. It plays almost like a "rules discovery" game (even though it's not; every mechanic is accompanied by a tutorial). The variety of rules set it apart from games like last year's Nurikabe World, which felt much more repetitive (if just as nicely presented).
The scrolling overworld is an interesting approach. It lets the puzzle breathe a bit, further helping the nonstop puzzle solving that many of its contemporaries suffer from.
I was a little underwhelmed by the controller support. It definitely worked, but it's just a way to drive the cursor. It's a keyboard/mouse game at heart.
Verdict: Simple, yet compelling. Will play slowly.
Big Walk

I'm currently partway through a Big Walk with 2 friends, but early impressions have been very positive. It's unerringly pleasant and so full of life. The sound design is perfect and it's leisurely pace fits the relaxed atmosphere of the game so well. Communication as a gameplay mechanic is just fun and it creates such an engaging, human experience. A total triumph of game design.
Verdict: Currently playing and loving it!
Burn With Me

In my article "Burn With Me" is spooky deckbuilding fun, I concluded:
Relentlessly focused and original, this small game packs a big punch.
- Small, focused design has no bloat.
- A fresh spin on rogue-like deckbuilders.
- You can find yourself in unwinnable states, which can be frustrating.
Score based on my 4-point rating scale.
Colorbound

A cute little puzzle platformer. Its presentation reminded me a lot of Carto, which is high praise. The puzzles were strong and there's an excellent hint system that drip-feeds you steps to get you unblocked. The puzzles are easy to explain, but hard enough that you have to actually consider your moves if you don't want to end up backed into a corner. Strong story with a good sense of place, too; there aren't many (any?) South American games, so it's a fun change of pace!
Verdict: Charming! Will likely revisit.
Deductopia

It's Golden Idol, but for playground-level mishaps instead of supernatural murder. The UI is pretty clean and the puzzles aren't too tough. I found the art style a little rough around the edges, but it's a well built experience overall. I'll basically never turn down a well made Idol-like!
Verdict: Right up my alley; will finish it soon.
EMUUROM

A clear descendent of the Animal Well school of puzzle platformers with many secrets. But despite loving its predecessor, EMUUROM didn't do it for me. Part of it was the stripped-down art style, which made legibility tough. The platforming didn't feel especially good either, which hurt when that's what you're doing a lot of. It didn't feel especially precise, though I expect it's much deeper than I understood while I played.
Scanning flora and fauna to learn how they interact with the world is a great concept. But unfortunately, the actual execution just didn't click for me.
Verdict: Interesting, but not for me.
Hamstermind

In my article "Hamstermind" is an eclectic puzzle adventure that's as challenging as it is charming, I concluded:
Eclectic, layered puzzles and charming presentation make for a cozy little adventure.
- A variety of puzzle types keeps gameplay fresh.
- Friendly, cartoonish graphics evoke the best of the PS2 era.
- Optional late game puzzles were underwhelming.
Score based on my 4-point rating scale.
He Who Watches

In my article "He Who Watches" disrespects gravity, I concluded:
These mind-bending puzzles are a masterclass in creative design.
- Unique traversal that's immediately intuitive
- Puzzles are both simple, hard, and intricate
- Playable hint system helps you while still making you work for it
- Hint system only walks you through a single trick, so if it doesn't unstick you in hard levels, you're out of luck
- Subtle lovecraftian theming didn't do much for me
Score based on my 4-point rating scale.
Horse Magnifier

This is a very funny concept for a game but lost its luster after about 10 levels. It's cute, but didn't really feel like it had legs. That said, I am morbidly curious about what jump scares the game has (though not enough to turn them on and find out).
Verdict: Didn't hold my attention, won't revisit.
The Incident at Galley House

In my article "The Incident at Galley House" reimagines a modern classic, I concluded:
A fresh coat of paint brings the brilliance of a beloved but niche game to a wider audience
- Excellent voice acting helps emotional scenes pop.
- The art is beautiful, really setting the scene.
- An expanded ending provides narrative closure not present in the original.
- Information density in the UI is lower than I'd like.
Score based on my 4-point rating scale.
Map Map

In my article "Map Map" turns triangulation into triumph, I concluded:
Utterly original gameplay and charming aesthetics make for a good time.
- Core gameplay is fun and original
- Story and characters are unflinchingly charming
- Map map, map map map!
- Some puzzles can be obtuse
- Loses a little focus in the late game; some mechanics feel unnecessary
Score based on my 4-point rating scale.
The Mermaid Mask

A narrative murder mystery with (simple so far) puzzles, executed well. UI is smooth and the characters are memorable. The full voice acting is a nice touch too. Everyone is appropriately cartoonish and the art direction is excellent overall. And it's a locked-door mystery!
Verdict: Definitely going to keep playing.
The Message from Deep Space

It gives strong Chants of Sennar crossed with Contact, where you iteratively decode an unfamiliar language using mathematical fundamentals (and more!). I've heard it gets much harder, but the difficulty curve has been pretty smooth through the first few chapters.
The UI chrome is nicely designed and fits the 70s computer vibe well. There's a pleasant amount of story and I appreciated that it permeated the whole experience rather than feeling bolted on. It's a simple concept well executed and I am on board!
Verdict: Pulled me in quickly. Definitely going to play more.
Opus Magnum: De Re Metallica

Given that Opus Magnum is one of my all time favorites, it should come as no surprise that I really enjoyed (what I played of) this surprise DLC. There are some neat new mechanics, but it's mostly more of the same. But when the same is so good, you can't really ask for much more.
Verdict: Will definitely play when I have the time.
Order of the Sinking Star

OotSS has a lot going for it: a surprising amount of narrative, a metric tonne of puzzles, and nice art direction. The puzzles were tightly designed and each had something to teach or prove. As an adaptation of 4 other games, it works well. I didn't make it far enough to see any mechanic mixing between areas, but I imagine that'll be pretty cool.
I enjoyed each of the starting areas, but found some of the mechanics in the east and south a little tricky for my taste. I appreciated that I could wander elsewhere when I got stuck, but I'm not sure how long I'd stick with it. HTLB records 40 hours to reach an ending and more than 130 hours to 100%... which is too many hours. I usually don't have the patience for that sort of thing.
Definitely a great game for puzzle sickos though!
Verdict: Will probably play some more, but can't imagine I'll finish it.
Phonopolis

A fun little audio-based dystopia. The animations are phenomenal, but I'd expect nothing less from the team behind Machinarium. It feels like a playable Laika movie.
The puzzles are simple, but fun. The whole thing feel smore comedic than thinky, which is a fun change of pace.
Verdict: Will definitely finish!
Schrodinger's Cat Burglar

A nicely-polished game about a cat burglar who can be in two places at once. The story was light, but charmed me out of the gate. The puzzles were pretty straightforward (which tracks- it's nominated for Best Accessible Game) but I suspect they'll get harder. Held items being temporarily duplicated between cats seems like a pretty deep vein to pull from.
Controlling both cats at once reminded me of Semispheres, which is always a good thing. I'll be curious to see how they push that mechanic, since that particular strand of mental strain is both fun and unusual.
I also appreciated the co-op support, which is a rarity in puzzle games. Probably less antagonistic than co-op favorite Death Squared, but you never know!
Verdict: Very cute! Will revisit.
Shroom and Gloom

A refreshing take on the roguelike deckbuilder formula. There's no defense, but there's a lot of healing. You can permanently modify cards, which leads to some pretty goofy combos. And you're managing two decks at once: one for combat and once for between rooms. It's a neat concept that works well.
There's basically no downtime though, so my runs took a fair amount of focus. The art style isn't really for me (too gooey) but it's certainly supported by a strong vision. I'll be curious to see what else they add during the early access period!
Verdict: Will give it a go once it's out of early access.
The Red Pearls of Borneo

When I played Borneo earlier this year, I wrote:
Heavily inspired by "Type Help", it does a good job carving out its own niche with a larger cast, multiple sections, and a visual interface to help your solve. I loved how much actual history it wove into the storyThe gameplay itself follows a tried-and-true formula, but I found the game itself a little rough around the edges. The UX had lots of little papercuts and there were a _lot_ of typos. It's free, so one can only expect so much, but it still soured the experience a bit. In a game consisting of mostly text, your text must be correct. Plus, the back quarter of the game drags a bit- it's not a bad story, but it's a lot of clicking and not much solving. I liked the pseudo-interactive nature of the epilogues, but they felt slow compared to the actual puzzles.But, these are all fixable in a sequel! I hope it gets the care and attention the format deserves.
And luckily, a sequel is on the way! Green Mist Over Portland is in active development. I've already confirmed that the developer has shored up my major complaints about Red Pearls, so I imagine I'll have little to complain about.
The Remake of the End of the Greatest RPG of All Time

Taking the award for both highest concept and longest name, TRotEotGRPGoAT is a total trip. You jump into the last hour of a remastered version of a thin pastiche of Chrono Trigger. You don't have any context, but you're max level and have tons of items already, because the save file you're using is already at the end of the game. You're soon puzzling your way through the enigmatic end-game combat and references to the adventure you must have had to have gotten here.
There are also interstitial segments where you wander around a virtual world outside the game, solving more puzzles and watching clips from the documentary that's being made about the development of the game that you've been playing. There's also pages of the game's manual to find (a la Tunic), cluing you in about how the game works.
The puzzles are straightforward so far, but the experience is wild. It's all mad brilliance and I am absolutely here for it.
Verdict: Absolutely going to play, I need to see where it goes.
TRACE: SHAPE

TRACE (and its expansion, SHAPE) are both escape-room style point-and-click games set in an uncanny little sci-fi planet. The puzzles were approachable and the art direction is excellent. Everything feels tactile, which is good when you're exploring and poking at things. As a dedicated escape room veteran, this is right up my alley.
Verdict: Will definitely finish (and play the base game too).
Titanium Court

I heard a lot of buzz about this one when the IGF awards were happening last year and boy did it deliver. It's a match-3 / resource management / auto-battler / rogue-like all tied together with some stunningly written dialogue and meta-narrative.
The actual match-3 / combat gameplay is reasonably strategic without being too pushing. But I'm absolutely hooked on everything else surrounding the core gameplay. I know I'll need to see this one through.
Verdict: Bizarre and unique. Must see more.
TR-49

A document discovery game in the vein of Galley House, which is right up my alley. It took a few minutes to wrap my head around what was going on, but I was sold on it once I got my feet under me.
There are a lot of layers of narrative happening, but it rewards players who can absorb everything. I loved that the game records important information as you go, saving me the trouble of determining the importance of every snippet. It's convenient, but threatens to streamline the experience a little too much. Sometimes that's what the doctor ordered though.
The production value is through the roof, with full voice acting and fluid animations. Story is a little slow, but I'm interested enough to see where it'll go. Inkle, the developer, has put out consistently good work, so I'm confident they'll stick the landing.
Verdict: Interesting concept that I'm excited to see through to the end.
That's all for now
What a year! The competition is stiff as always, but I'm happy with my picks. Congrats to all the nominees and thanks again to the Thinky Games folks. Until next year!