poster for The Banner Saga

The Banner Saga

Genre: Tactics

I've played the main story 1 time and given it an average score of 2 (out of 4).

2021-11-13 9h 0m First Time

I liked the idea of this a lot, but it failed to come together for me. The story was decent and suitably grim/bleak, but the gameplay was clunky. As a tactics game, it's missing lots of QoL that other similar games have (especially FE), such as camera rotation, undo move, and attack range filters. Character upgrading is neat, but it's super stingy with poitns. Also, chracters can die/lieave at any time, which feels extra bad when you just dumped a ton of resources into them. The mechanics around the "oregon trail" part where you build strength in your crew is fine, but isn't well explained/super relevant. Some good ideas, but didn't land.

If you liked this review and want to read more like it, subscribe via RSS Feeds, Bluesky, Mastodon, or: